Robin's Steamers

[NeutronIC]

Just wanted to say how good it is to see more high quality GWR steam back on the front page - thanks Robin

Matt.

[1crick14a]

I see he has also put his own collection on a CD available if you write to him £4.50 usual fee and 6 quid overseas.............Rick

[davepascoe]

can't agree more !!!

Well done Robin.

[jp4712]

Very much agreed - quality stuff, thank you and well done. Now Robin, if you only had loyalties to Horwich...

Paul

[robin]

Just wanted to say how good it is to see more high quality GWR steam back on the front page - thanks Robin

Matt.

Thanks, your welcome.

I will be putting up a lot of the old stuff again (some updates) over the next few weeks and some news ones too.

[gopher]

Just a thank you to Robin for the excellent update to the County Class. Looks wonderful in front of a few clerestories. Looking forward to the curved frame variant.

Gordon

[duckweed]

Top quality and in my collection. great work Robin and using Canvas now I see.

Regards,

~Terry~

[robin]

Thanks chaps.

County of Brecon with the curved front of the frame etc. to follow shortly and since the basics are much the same I got carried away and added one too many wheels and came up with a Mogul. As you will see form the picy below some work to do still on the shape and textures but not too far off now.


Click the image to zoom in

[davidaward]

Wow can't wait to see that one, any chance of the different cab variations as well?

[robin]

Wow can't wait to see that one, any chance of the different cab variations as well?

I expect I will do the later Large Collet cab too.

[longbow]

Great stuff Robin. Moguls have been a big gap in the GWR MSTS roster. BR liveries too, please!

[timbooth]

Lovely model as always.

However [diving for cover] - thats really a 93XX though, as the 43XX/53XX/63XX/73XX all had horizontal reversers and a wider, elongated, centre splasher underneath it - however, the 93XX also had outside steam pipes. The GWR never did grasp the standardisation concept!

Plenty of scope though for shape and texture variations though, and looking forward to seeing all of them

[robin]

Lovely model as always.

However [diving for cover] - thats really a 93XX though, as the 43XX/53XX/63XX/73XX all had horizontal reversers and a wider, elongated, centre splasher underneath it - however, the 93XX also had outside steam pipes. The GWR never did grasp the standardisation concept!

Plenty of scope though for shape and texture variations though, and looking forward to seeing all of them

Watch out... incoming!

As I mentioned this is not complete shape wise but it will be an early 43xx. As you say the middle splasher on the reverser side should be elongated and I need to lower reverser itself. This representation at the moment is a bit of a bitser in that most of the things put together have come off other locos I have built. So, perhaps they did have some standardisation.

The cab (although not obvious from the screenshot) is the early short cab it would have to have the collett cab for a 93xx for instance. Also the later series locos had a different reinforcement support under the boiler/above the crosshead bars. So, on balance Its nowhere near a 93xx I think the model leans much more to a 43xx than later series including tall safety valve and absence of outside steam pipes etc.

The point of standardisation is always one for debate I guess. When you consider the state of afairs before Churchward started his programme where engines of the same class could have quite significant differences his work showed the way to many others. Also I don't think it is reasonable to expect a design to stay exactly the same throughout the long timespan this and many other loco types were in production.