Page 5 of 12

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 2:07 pm
by gptech
kev2003 wrote:happily the industry moved forward
the secondman might not have been so happy if it meant he was redundant......

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 4:50 pm
by 749006
rkk01 wrote:Could it ever run again???

Pragmatism says not, but the prototype HST has been revived and extinct steam classes reincarnated.
Of course, it's money and will power that makes the difference - just look at what happens in the world of rare warbirds...

But, from an engineering perspective, how dead is a dead APT???
I would say as dead as the DoDo

There are so many items on the APT which were unique to that train - the brakes were Hydrokinetic, using liquids to slow the train down.
Tilting system was totally advanced - more than the later Pendolino & Voyagers.

Although it would be nice to see it running again I don't think it would happen.

Peter

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 5:04 pm
by Mr395008
deltic009 wrote:Much more on topic. An in-depth look at the APT-P, note the two drivers in the cab. It sounds (description of features etc) and looks fabulous.

https://train-simulator.com/apt-p-detail/

As an aside, regarding the trackside transponders for speed, depending how these work and if they're scenario specific, if we understand how they work might we be able to use them as a way of fudging limits for rolling stock below normal linespeed for use in scenarios I wonder??

Deffo my favourite shot, cracking detail in there.
APT_0009.jpg
Whoa. Impressive!

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 5:11 pm
by 749006
Mr395008 wrote:
deltic009 wrote:Much more on topic. An in-depth look at the APT-P, note the two drivers in the cab. It sounds (description of features etc) and looks fabulous.

https://train-simulator.com/apt-p-detail/

As an aside, regarding the trackside transponders for speed, depending how these work and if they're scenario specific, if we understand how they work might we be able to use them as a way of fudging limits for rolling stock below normal linespeed for use in scenarios I wonder??

Deffo my favourite shot, cracking detail in there.
The attachment APT_0009.jpg is no longer available
Whoa. Impressive!
It does look realistic :)
Crewe CS
Crewe CS
Peter

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 7:21 pm
by johnrossetti
There is a fund raising effort to get the powercar from Coventry to Crewe as they only have one, I think they have raised enough to do it now
https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/apt

I suspect a paint job will be next !
http://hampo.uk/2017/10/sent-to-coventry/

John

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 8:52 pm
by fudginator1
Obviously there was a few problems with the APT technically, with it possibly being put into service too quickly.
The thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Thu Nov 30, 2017 10:40 pm
by sbowness
johnrossetti wrote:There is a fund raising effort to get the powercar from Coventry to Crewe as they only have one, I think they have raised enough to do it now
https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/apt

I suspect a paint job will be next !
http://hampo.uk/2017/10/sent-to-coventry/

John
The appeal has reached its target but Brian is more than happy to receive anything on top as that will go towards preparing it for display. He has some great plans for it. Details are on the Facebook page:

https://www.facebook.com/AptPUkClass370/

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 3:37 pm
by 749006
fudginator1 wrote:Obviously there was a few problems with the APT technically, with it possibly being put into service too quickly.
The thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?
When the APT came out the larger windows made the tilt more noticeable and the talk of people being sick put that thought in to peoples minds

Some people today still feel sick travelling on Pendolinos - especially if you go backwards

Peter

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 5:16 pm
by gptech
fudginator1 wrote:The thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?
The tilt on the APT was so smooth you didn't realise you were tilting until you looked out of the window---that confused many people's minds, hence the nausea. The Pendo's (and all other subsequent tilting systems) introduced a barely susceptible 'sense of movement' before the curves so that the brain could come to terms with the fact that the axis had shifted.
Tilting trains are meant to help reduce the effects of centrifugal force on the human body, but they can still cause nausea, a problem that was widely seen on early "active" tilting trains that exactly balanced the outward force. The effect could be felt under maximum speed and tilt, when the combination of tilting outside view and lack of corresponding sideways force can be disconcerting to passengers, like that of a "thrill ride". Researchers have found that if the tilting motion is reduced to compensate for 80% or less of lateral apparent force, then passengers feel more secure. Also, motion sickness on tilting trains can be essentially eliminated by adjusting the timing of when the cars tilt as they enter and leave the curves. Systems typically tilt the cars based on a sensor at the front of the train, and the slight delay in reacting to this information leads to a short period of sideways force while the cars react. It was found that when the cars tilt just at the beginning of the curves instead of while they are making the turns, there was no motion sickness. To provide information about the upcoming curves before the front of the train reaches them, a GPS system is used.[4]
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tilting_train)

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 5:18 pm
by GrateEastern
According to one documentary I've seen, quite a bit of the sickness came from the presspack and VIPs. Many of whom were sloshed before they boarded the infamous official launch train.

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 5:45 pm
by 749006
I had 3 enjoyable trips, twice Preston - Euston and once Euston - Stafford :)

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 6:26 pm
by Springer6
fudginator1 wrote:Obviously there was a few problems with the APT technically, with it possibly being put into service too quickly.
The thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?
What made the press pack feel sick was excessive amounts of free BR alcohol. It's done that to me few times ! :lol:

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 6:29 pm
by david1
fudginator1 wrote:he thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?
The APT tilt system compensated for 100% of the curvature, where`s the class 390`s and other tilting trains only compensate for around 85-90% of the curve, because of the full compensation that why some passengers felt travel sickness, and in the Pendolino`s you still feel a small amount of sideways force while taking the curves.

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 6:39 pm
by 749006
david1 wrote:
fudginator1 wrote:he thing for me which I can't quite grasp is there was loads of talk back then about passenger sickness, so what doesn't the 390's do the the APT did?
The APT tilt system compensated for 100% of the curvature, where`s the class 390`s and other tilting trains only compensate for around 85-90% of the curve, because of the full compensation that why some passengers felt travel sickness, and in the Pendolino`s you still feel a small amount of sideways force while taking the curves.
Which it basically what it says in Gary's post above

Re: There will be an APT-P DLC!!!

Posted: Fri Dec 01, 2017 6:50 pm
by johnrossetti
Comparing the pictures between the APT for TS and the real APT, I notice the oval buffers under the nose are horizontal in one picture and vertical in the other

Did they swivel ?

John