Total rant on railsim 2012

General discussion about RailWorks, your thoughts, questions, news and views!

Moderator: Moderators

Locked
dave138
Getting the hang of things now
Posts: 12
Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2005 12:01 am

Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by dave138 »

Rail simulator is becoming a very expensive game to play, with all due respects RSC and steam with with the average route costing £20+ and train costing £10 upward we have now been “treated with railsim 2012” that unless you do not have a PC with the test specs RSC were trying, your basically boned. I had WCMLN which run like a charm , now a total write off, and with other routes. I’m now looking at the forums and it seems that a PC upgrade is the only answer . (£500+) to be honest it’s not worth it. RANT OVER
User avatar
Darpor
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 7322
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2008 8:51 pm

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by Darpor »

dave138 wrote: that unless you do not have a PC with the test specs RSC were trying, your basically boned.
Lovely rant, but completely wrong, especially the above bit. By all means be unhappy, but don't post bull.
DPSimulation - http://www.dpsimulation.org.uk/ - Free High Speed Downloads of TS2012 Content

DPSimulation Blog - http://dpsimulation.blogspot.co.uk/ - News, Views & Development Updates
User avatar
gavo01
Well Established Forum Member
Posts: 824
Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2009 9:55 pm

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by gavo01 »

I've yet to upgrade partly due to reading how other members with similar PC specs have been doing since the upgrade.

Did you make a back up of RW2 before upgrading? If you did then just return to RW2 until you feel the justification for shelling out the money for a new PC.

If you didn't then I'm afraid to say that you and everyone else was advised to beforehand.
User avatar
1S811985
Well Established Forum Member
Posts: 655
Joined: Wed Oct 20, 2010 8:03 pm
Location: Kelvin Valley

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by 1S811985 »

Darpor wrote: Lovely rant, but completely wrong...
Really? It is expensive. RW3 dosen't run as well in legacy mode as it was promised it would. It dosen't run properly at all in TS2012 mode for a lot of us. Upgrades are already being thrown around this forum as the silver bullet. Seems to me that Dave138 got a lot completely right.
gavo01 wrote: Did you make a back up of RW2 before upgrading? If you did then just return to RW2 until you feel the justification for shelling out the money for a new PC.

If you didn't then I'm afraid to say that you and everyone else was advised to beforehand.
RSDerek advised users to back up our own work, not clone the entire game. And there's that assumption that people are just going to go and upgrade their systems. I think its bang out of order to try and suggest that users are at fault, either for not backing up to the Yangtse or for not having the right hardware, when we were promised by RSC that things would run just as well in legacy mode.

1S81
I know what gold does to men's souls.
User avatar
Darpor
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 7322
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2008 8:51 pm

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by Darpor »

1S811985 wrote: Really? It is expensive. RW3 dosen't run as well in legacy mode as it was promised it would. It dosen't run properly at all in TS2012 mode for a lot of us. Upgrades are already being thrown around this forum as the silver bullet. Seems to me that Dave138 got a lot completely right.
Did you actually read the bit I had quoted? I'll do it again.
dave138 wrote: that unless you do not have a PC with the test specs RSC were trying, your basically boned.
Not completely right, completely wrong. It's incorrect.
DPSimulation - http://www.dpsimulation.org.uk/ - Free High Speed Downloads of TS2012 Content

DPSimulation Blog - http://dpsimulation.blogspot.co.uk/ - News, Views & Development Updates
User avatar
FoggyMorning
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 5382
Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 1:16 am
Location: In the not too distant future, next Sunday A.D.

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by FoggyMorning »

1S811985 wrote:
Darpor wrote: Lovely rant, but completely wrong...
Really? It is expensive. RW3 dosen't run as well in legacy mode as it was promised it would. It dosen't run properly at all in TS2012 mode for a lot of us. Upgrades are already being thrown around this forum as the silver bullet. Seems to me that Dave138 got a lot completely right.
gavo01 wrote: Did you make a back up of RW2 before upgrading? If you did then just return to RW2 until you feel the justification for shelling out the money for a new PC.

If you didn't then I'm afraid to say that you and everyone else was advised to beforehand.
RSDerek advised users to back up our own work, not clone the entire game. And there's that assumption that people are just going to go and upgrade their systems. I think its bang out of order to try and suggest that users are at fault, either for not backing up to the Yangtse or for not having the right hardware, when we were promised by RSC that things would run just as well in legacy mode.

1S81
Speaking only for myself, the game is running better in so-called legacy mode than RW2 did

Steve
NeutronIC
Atomic Systems Team
Atomic Systems Team
Posts: 11085
Joined: Fri Oct 05, 2001 12:00 am
Location: E11, London, England
Contact:

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by NeutronIC »

Just want to agree with Darren on this one, I've got TS2012 working quite acceptably (about as well as RW2 did) on a 7 yr old laptop. No 2012 mode but then I think that would be asking a bit much for something that old.

Matt.


Sent from my Transformer TF101 using Tapatalk
User avatar

Easilyconfused
Worried about Silent Chickens
Posts: 13205
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2002 9:06 am
Location: Portsmouth & Bristol
Contact:

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by Easilyconfused »

Darren and a couple of others beat me to the posting button.

This thread appears to be going nowhere fast. It is clear there are issues for some and RS.Com need the full details to their support email address. Grumbling about things here will not change anything.

Nobody is "boned" or been had-over (to use another phrase I have seen hurled around). The update was well publicised as was the need to get offline in Steam if you really wanted to avoid it (OK there were issues in doing that if you got the new client but those are totally out of the control of RS.Com). I suspect RS.Com had a busy day on Friday with emails and now it is the weekend.

They need to be given a little time to find out the cause of some of the issues. Yes, I know that is frustrating for all concerned but they are a commercial operation and these things take time.

FWIW I am still waiting on a response from EA Games about a different game with a problem 2 months after I submitted the fault log and in my day job I have a ticket open at our main supplier for over a month and we pay a 6 figure licence and support fee every year .....

Now, if you haven't got anything constructive to say then think about whether you need to say it.
Kindest regards

John Lewis

Member of the forum moderation team
tofwings
Established Forum Member
Posts: 314
Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2004 12:21 pm
Location: Wolverhampton

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by tofwings »

I had WCMLN which run like a charm , now a total write off,
Sorry dude , gotta disagree,

My Machine is by no means new , yet im getting fps between 20 and 30 on this route with all settings on high inc shadows ,Bloom and Depth of field ( i have screenshots if you need proof )

Granted it drops to 14 fps in places but on the whole its very good ,
All i want now is the Class 86 to be converted to show rain on the Windscreen and i will be very happy

Cheers
Brian

Specs are
Abit ip35 pro
3.00ghz intel core 2 duo
8Gb ram
ATI 6870 1Gb GDDR5 Mem
Win 7 64 bit
40" Samsung native res 1920 x 1080 ( full Screen )
User avatar
cambrian06
Been on the forums for a while
Posts: 271
Joined: Tue May 02, 2006 2:51 pm
Location: West Midlands

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by cambrian06 »

Hi everyone,
As a latecomer to Railworks (decided to give it a try when it was offered in the Steam sale last Christmas for £4.50) I must say I wasn't impressed with it at the time and it hasn't had much use. I didn't find it particulary immersive and I just could't get on with the scenario editor. This may be heresy on this forum but I find the MSTS activity editor much more logical and intuitive.
Anyway now to TS2012, having downloaded the upgrade I wasn't too surprised to find that my 2007 hardware couldn't manage TSX. I am however quite pleased with the improvements when running in so called legacy mode, I have been able to increase some detail settings and still get reasonable frame rates but most importantly the general appearance of the sim is improved, particulary the lighting, and as a bonus I get the cab sway effect as well. Overall it has made the driving experience in Railworks a little more enjoyable. Now I just have to have another go at getting to grips with the editor and who knows I might just become a convert.
On the issue of having to upgrade hardware, as a long time user of MSTS I eventually got to the point where to get the best out of that sim I had to upgrade and my current PC was custom built with that in mind, now at 4 years old it is hopelessly out of date, I'm afraid thats just a fact of life with computers, a year is a very long time when it comes to technological advancement.
As a final footnote I would comment that it would be helpful if games producers were more realistic in defining the system specs required for their products, most seem to seriously under estimate the minimum specs needed to run at a reasonable level.

Regards,
Andy
User avatar
smarty2
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 9976
Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2005 8:16 am
Location: 1963, at Snow Hill!
Contact:

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by smarty2 »

Seems a lot of problems are caused by some not updating their graphics drivers? (can't speak for ATI) but my system is kak compared to most of the people having issues but lets be clear the game is optimised for Nvidia gpu/chipsets. I have had the latest drivers since release and they work fine in TS2012 along with my underated quad core phenom (2.2ghz) 8800gtx, oooold m2n sli by asus and 4 gig of 800mhz ram, rubbish brand. I am running TS2012 with the AA slider on 5 but can run it on 7 with slow downs all settings on high except water, passengers and detail set on 8, no bloom or depth, procedural. Certainly I can qualify my system/me are not "boned"! :roll:
Best Regards
Martin (smarty2)
Non technically minded individual!

Is There A God?
Dudley Bible web page
User avatar
Merlin75
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 2205
Joined: Wed Apr 07, 2010 9:13 pm
Location: Cornwall

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by Merlin75 »

Just to add my 4year old PC could not run RW2 that great but can run RW3 with TSX on full settings minus shadows. So it is strange to see that people with alot more powerful & modern PC than me are having problems with the game. I have a I7-920 2.6ghz/ 8GB ram/ 9800gt 1GB graphic card.
[album 241806 sig.jpg]
USRailFan
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 4226
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 8:07 am
Location: Norway

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by USRailFan »

I'd think its the acres of RAM and the 1gig graphics card that does it.
I'm not fat - I'm easy to see
User avatar
august1929
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 1526
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2006 5:07 pm

Re: Total rant on railsim 2012

Post by august1929 »

smarty2 wrote:Seems a lot of problems are caused by some not updating their graphics drivers? (can't speak for ATI)
Yep -upgrade of ATI drivers does the trick as well.

My computer is 5/6 years old - single core etc. etc. but with a decent graphics card. I can run WCML as well as before in legacy mode and overall, now I have worked out my own graphics settings, the visuals are A1. TSX doesn't particularly work for me (wouldn't expect it to) but no worse than I was before.

I did, however, back up my entire UK RW install - all 75 Gig of it, just in case.....

Original poster should give it another go - might need some fiddling, but if he could run RW2, then there appears to be a good chance he should be able to run RW3 (accepting there are some still with problems :( ).

Rod
Locked

Return to “[RW] General RW Discussion”