It is pretty darned good, but there are a few rough edges; some are around the route itself, e.g. I've spotted a catenary wire crossing the track at knee height just South of Rahway station where the North Jersey coast line branches off the mainline -- it's actually the wire that goes *under* the mainline, but it sticks up above it because the catenary is a fixed (high) height.
Then, as ICE mentioned, the cab of the AEM7 seems a bit "low-res" compared to some of the recent UK releases, e.g. the Class 86, the Class 67, the 421, the 450 -- it has a fuzzy, slightly out-of-focus appearance to some of the instrumentation and textures. This is strange as it's all where it should be and some of the pre-production shots over at RWA.com look quite amazing. Not sure what the issue is, possibly the MDF "worktop" texture bringing down everything else, possibly the overall darkness of it all, I'm not sure, but it just does
Great stuff that they got the official license from Amtrak, mind, but am I the only that thinks the finish of both loco and coaches could look more, umm, "aluminumy"{sic}?
Lastly, as already mentioned, the free-roams are all quite knackered and it's good to hear that RSC have already got a fix in the pipeline. I've a feeling that it's something to do with this weird thing at Adams -- check out the dev notes and the odd consist name...:
(click for full size)
Oh, and the first "proper" scenario I tried did this somewhere South of Metropark
It's a shame that the last bit of polish wasn't there when it went out the door, but if RSC can squash the buggies PDQ, this addon will undoubtedly be a boon for them and net them a lot more customers.
Personally, I'd still give it an 8/10 on first impressions just for the amount of route detail, the new assets, oh and like Bill said, the fact that it runs decent frame-rates without needing a mega-spec PC.
Going to go play some more
Rik.