Fumes

Discussion relating to the operations of real railways together with the experiences of the people who work (or have worked) on them.

Moderator: Moderators

User avatar
Hymek
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 2270
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 am
Location: 38A/85D
Contact:

Re: Fumes

Post by Hymek »

I cant comment on the voyager engines running when stabled in stations. I know for a fact in the 1980s with the peaks, the drivers were told not to switch them off at St Panc due to the fact they wouldnt be able to get them started again.

One reason for switching 1st Gen units off is to minimize clag from what im guestimating. As sitting around for an hour and with the length of an exhaust on something like a 108 is very long, so the claggy fumes collect in the exhaust, and when the units leave, hey presto, muchos clag!

But yeah, on the voyagers it is probably to keep the electrical systems inside (such as the fridges) cool.
http://www.svr-dmu.org.uk - DMU Group WM
http://www.englishelectricpreservation.co.uk/ - English Electric Preservation

Producer of Rolling Stock for the UKTS community Since September 2002
User avatar
Kromaatikse
For Quality & Playability
Posts: 2733
Joined: Fri Jun 12, 2009 5:39 pm
Location: Helsinki

Re: Fumes

Post by Kromaatikse »

Wait, doesn't St. Pancras have a decent overall roof? Why would it be more difficult to start a Peak there than in the open air?

The "claggy fumes" on 1st-gen units probably refers to carried-over oil and unburned fuel. When the exhaust system heats up due to the engine coming under load again, this collected gunge starts to burn - *inside* the exhaust. That was also a problem on Westerns due to their two-stroke engines, but not so much on full-sized four-stroke diesels.

This is also why you get a very dirty exhaust from a diesel with a blown turbo. There isn't enough air getting to the engine to burn all the fuel it's being fed, so it burns in the exhaust instead. Modern diesels have an oxygen sensor in the exhaust which restricts the fuel rate to avoid fuel carry-over, even with a blown turbo - hence, much less clag.

It turns out that the Valenta didn't much like being idled forever either, during the hybrid-set runs before the Mk4 DVTs were built, so they started using the extra power from the engine to avoid ruining it.
The key to knowledge is not to rely on others to teach you it.
AndyUK
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 3135
Joined: Thu Aug 15, 2002 7:57 pm

Re: Fumes

Post by AndyUK »

Kromaatikse wrote:.....That was also a problem on Westerns due to their two-stroke engines.....
Two-stroke diesels in a Western, I don't think so! I assume you mean Deltics.

Andy L
User avatar
Hymek
Very Active Forum Member
Posts: 2270
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 am
Location: 38A/85D
Contact:

Re: Fumes

Post by Hymek »

Kromaatikse wrote:Wait, doesn't St. Pancras have a decent overall roof? Why would it be more difficult to start a Peak there than in the open air?

The "claggy fumes" on 1st-gen units probably refers to carried-over oil and unburned fuel. When the exhaust system heats up due to the engine coming under load again, this collected gunge starts to burn - *inside* the exhaust. That was also a problem on Westerns due to their two-stroke engines, but not so much on full-sized four-stroke diesels.

This is also why you get a very dirty exhaust from a diesel with a blown turbo. There isn't enough air getting to the engine to burn all the fuel it's being fed, so it burns in the exhaust instead. Modern diesels have an oxygen sensor in the exhaust which restricts the fuel rate to avoid fuel carry-over, even with a blown turbo - hence, much less clag.

It turns out that the Valenta didn't much like being idled forever either, during the hybrid-set runs before the Mk4 DVTs were built, so they started using the extra power from the engine to avoid ruining it.
No, it has nothing to do with the air, Its just that if they shut them down at St.P they couldnt get them started again due to the worn nature of the Peaks at that point
http://www.svr-dmu.org.uk - DMU Group WM
http://www.englishelectricpreservation.co.uk/ - English Electric Preservation

Producer of Rolling Stock for the UKTS community Since September 2002
Locked

Return to “Real Railway Discussion”